This morning someone asked me a simple-sounding question: “Should I store my photos in a cardboard box or a plastic box?”
At first glance, it feels like a straightforward choice. But the truth is, the “right” answer depends on something much bigger: what’s your goal for these photos?
When Photos Are Just for Your Own Memories
Now, let’s be honest: not every photo we print is meant to last forever. Often, we just want a neat, organized way to keep the pictures that matter most to us.
In this case, either cardboard or plastic will do the job. Personally, I keep my photos in a shoebox-style box, it’s simple, easy to access, and fits right on a shelf. But there are so many beautiful and functional storage options available today. (I’ll share some of my favorites from Amazon below.)
When Photos Are Meant to Last Generations
If your goal is to protect heirloom photos (prints you hope to pass down for generations) a good choice is an archival photo storage box. These are made from special acid-free materials that won’t deteriorate your photos or alter their colors over time. This type of box is designed with preservation in mind, making it ideal for safeguarding your family’s most valuable prints. Think of things like protection from fading and discoloration. Archival Methods is one place you can find these special boxes.
However, these prints are still at risk. Disasters like fire, flood or even just a leaky pipe in the house could lead to bigger problems…. even destroyed photos.
When Photos Are Truly Irreplaceable
If you want to make sure your photos are truly safe there are options that can give you even more peace of mind. That’s when it’s time to look beyond ordinary storage boxes.
For irreplaceable items, you’ll want a fireproof and waterproof box. These are designed to withstand disasters that would ruin any cardboard or plastic option. When choosing one, check for the fire safety rating and compare how waterproof the box actually is (some can be submerged for hours, others only protect against splashes).
It’s important to note that those rubber totes, even the ones with tight seals, don’t offer real protection from water. After Hurricane Ian, I saw firsthand how they gave many families only a false sense of security. When the floodwaters came, those boxes did nothing to keep photos safe.
I’ve spent time researching these waterproof and fireproof options and even consulted with professionals about the best solutions for protecting treasured family memories. That, along with a methods for selecting and storing those photos is what I’ll be talking about at the Memory Keepers Live Summit next week.
A Deeper Dive at Memory Keepers Live
If this topic has you thinking about your own photo collection, I’d love to invite you to join me at the Memory Keepers Live Summit. In my session, The Grab & Go Box, I’ll reveal everything I’ve learned about choosing the right kind of storage, plus share practical tips for creating a box that will withstand time – and even disaster.
My class isn’t just about picking a box though. It’s about protecting your family’s legacy so it can be passed down for generations, no matter what storms come your way.
👉 So, cardboard or plastic? The answer really depends on your purpose. Start by asking yourself: Do I want these photos to last for me… or forever?
Here are a few boxes from Amazon that would work well for keeping your collection neat and organized.
| Product Image | Product Name / Price | Primary Button |
|---|---|---|
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
|
And if you’re looking for even more help keeping your photos organized, check out the other ways we can connect and work together:
👉 Grab my free Photo Resource Guide – it’s packed with tools, apps, and simple steps to get started.
👉 Check out my book, Beyond the Storm – a powerful blend of true stories and practical advice for safeguarding your photos.
👉 Want to join the photo organizing CRUISE? This fun getaway is set for February 2026 and YOU are invited to join! Check out The Great Photo Voyage and be sure and sign up soon, space is limited!
Or follow along on social media! Check out Instagram and YouTube to get my latest information.